Guide

Recruitment guarantees, explained

What a 90 day hire guarantee should actually cover.

A plain-language guide for hiring managers comparing recruitment agencies in Australia — what the guarantee really means, what voids it, and why no AI screening changes the quality of what lands on your desk.

Four questions to ask before you sign terms

01

Replacement or refund?

A replacement guarantee obliges the agency to find someone else. A pro-rata refund gives your money back but leaves the vacancy open. Know which one you are buying.

02

How long does it run?

Thirty days rarely covers a full work cycle. Ninety days is where a mis-hire actually surfaces. Ask whether the period can be extended and at what cost.

03

What voids it?

Redundancy, restructure, a materially changed role and unpaid invoices are the usual exclusions. Get them in writing before the search starts, not after a placement fails.

04

Who screened the resumes?

If a filter sorted the applications, the guarantee is insuring a process no human reviewed. Ask directly whether a person read every application.

Why the guarantee matters more than the fee

Most hiring conversations start with the percentage. That is the wrong end of the deal. A cheap fee on a hire that walks in week six costs you the fee, the onboarding, the lost productivity, the team disruption and the whole search again.

A recruitment guarantee is the only part of the agreement that puts the agency's money where its judgement is. If an agency will not stand behind the placement for a meaningful period, that tells you what they think of their own shortlist.

What a 90 day hire guarantee should actually say

Our standard guarantee is straightforward: if you move the person on within the first 90 days, we replace them. No argument, no invoice for the second search. It is extendable to 180 days for a small additional fee where a role carries a longer ramp-up.

Ninety days works because it maps to reality. It covers the first full cycle of real deadlines, real pressure and real team dynamics — the conditions under which a mis-hire becomes obvious. Thirty days only tests whether someone can be pleasant in an induction.

No AI screening: why we read every resume

Automated screening rewards keyword density and penalises careers that do not run in a straight line. The tradesperson who moved into supervision, the operations manager who came out of a different industry, the returning parent with a two-year gap — all routinely filtered out before anyone reads a word.

We read every application. We look for transferable skills, because content can be taught and judgement usually cannot. That takes hours we do not bill separately, and it is the single biggest reason our shortlists are short.

Search, not advertising

Posting an ad collects whoever is actively looking. Searching finds the person who is doing the job well somewhere else and has never seen your role. We invest the hours in searching rather than in ad spend, and we ask non-standard questions to get at what actually motivates a candidate to move.

We only present candidates we believe fit. We do not pad a shortlist with maybes to hit a quota — a three-name shortlist you can act on beats ten you have to wade through.

Pilot candidates: a little longer up front, a shorter wait overall

We invest time up front to understand the role properly, then present 'pilot candidates' — an early calibration shortlist that tells us whether we have read the brief the way you meant it.

It adds a few days at the start and usually removes weeks at the end, because the second round is aimed correctly instead of guessing.

Common questions

What is a recruitment guarantee?
A promise with a period attached. If the placement does not last, the agency replaces them. The detail — length, replacement versus refund, exclusions — is where the value sits.
How long should it run?
Ninety days is the benchmark. It covers a full cycle of real work — the window where a mis-hire actually shows itself.
Does AI screening hurt hire quality?
It filters out good people. Keyword matching penalises transferable skills and non-linear careers. We read every resume instead.
What voids a guarantee?
Usually the things outside the hire. Redundancy, restructure, a materially changed role, unpaid invoices. Ask for the exclusions in writing.

Recruitment done differently

Search-led recruitment, every resume read by a person, and a standard 90 day hire guarantee behind the placement.

Got a role you need to get right?

admin@f4ps.com.au